Laclede County Record logo and header

Record investigates use of ALPRs

Kidnapped infant recovered within 90 minutes

Posted

In the midst of an investigative series of ALPRs, the camera technology aided in the rescue of a kidnapped 6-week-old infant.

On November 10, Lebanon Police received a report that an infant had been kidnapped. Officers arrived at the scene within five minutes and met with witnesses and the mother of the infant. The mother claimed the kidnapper was family and gave a brief description of the suspect and the vehicle she was driving.

After obtaining a license plate number, officers entered it into the ALPR systems. “Officers then placed the plate on a hot list, which automatically alerts surrounding agencies any time that plate is read by the ALPR camera,” said Lt. Kacie Springer. The officers tracked the vehicle, initiated a traffic stop, and safely recovered the infant.

With the aid of this technology, the police were able to locate the vehicle and the infant in just over an hour, according to the statement released by the Lebanon Police Department following the incident.

The Record reached out to Ambry Shaffer, a witness at the scene, who described the incident as “shocking” and praised the officers on scene for their responsiveness. Shaffer said she was wary of the technology, though the incident has given a different light to her perspective.

As of early November, there were a total of 11 ALPR cameras in Lebanon that were operable, Chief of Police Jerry Harrison said during the October interview referenced in last week’s ALPR story. Harrison anticipates adding 15-17 more cameras and is in the process of obtaining permits, though the timeline is unclear. His goal is to have 23 cameras total.

“It’s tedious, it’s frustrating, but if you’re making decisions that are impacting other people, those people need to be involved in the process,” he said. Harrison listed some of the departments that are frequently involved in the approval process, which included the Federal Highway Administration, MODOT, street and residential departments, electrical companies, and others.

Harrison discussed why having the camera technology makes sense from an officer staffing standpoint. He used $60,000 as a working cost of the LPR cameras in town, though he didn’t know the exact cost, and compared the number of cameras in town to roughly 80 officers.

“So I guess the way I look at it is, from a return on investment perspective, you’re getting the equivalent of 80-something officers, it makes the point, for 60k, you’re getting the service of this many police officers when most of the police officers, by the time you figure in car, equipment, training costs, all those costs, 60k probably doesn’t even field, barely field one police officer a year,” he said.

Harrison brought up the results of the October citizen surveys and said many people requested more police presence in neighborhoods. “Well how do we get more police in the neighborhood? By making more time for that officer to go do that.” ALPR usage is the most efficient way to make that time said Harrison.

Still, Harrison acknowledges the technology is unpopular. He mentioned he previously spoke with DeFlock Lebanon regarding compromises to the ALPR systems and said everything they have requested has been reasonable. Harrison explained, in his words, that DeFlock Lebanon said, “We don’t want LPR at all, we’re never going to be happy as long as you have LPR essentially, but we do appreciate that you’re doing this. We still don’t want you to have it, but we’re grateful that you’re doing this,” though Harrison said he was adlibbing those statements.

Harrison described a lockout feature, rolled out by Flock, that could be implemented in the LPD. “But as I understand it,” he said, “there’ll be a new feature that if you get, I don’t know how many of these flags, but if you get a flag, it’s going to not allow you access until someone with authority goes in and looks at it and verifies it was an appropriate use of the system.” Harrison said if a red flag appeared, it does not necessarily mean it’s misconduct, it just needs to be looked at.

Instances that constitute as questionable include numerous searches of the same plate by a single officer in a short span of time, however, this can include repeated searches on license plate variations, too. For example, if a witness of a hit-and-run misread an S in a plate for a 5, the officer would need to conduct searches that include those variations, as well as variations in vehicle make, model, and color.

The LPD has had a total of seven flagged activities since March, Harrison said during the interview. “So far, every time we’ve had that come up, we’re able to connect that to a police report. It’s timely and there’s a reasonable explanation.”

Chief Harrison said he wasn’t sure if the lockout feature was currently active at the time of the interview, though he said he would follow up with the Record regarding information on the feature and any potential updates released by Flock.